ABSTRACT
Over the last few years, we have gained insights into how immunotherapy, including checkpoint blockade, modulates key CD4 and CD8 T cell subsets in anti-tumor immunity. This information can now give us insights intohow immunotherapy can impact immunity in the setting of COVID-19. Indeed, we recently demonstrated that cancerpatients with T cell depletion have high COVID-19 mortality despite adequate B cell and antibody production, highlighting the importance of cellular immunity. Conversely, in the setting of B cell depletion by anti-CD20 therapy, CD8 T cells can compensate for impaired humoral immunity. PD-1 blockade increases the activation and proliferation of CD4 T follicular-helper cells, which plays a key role in promoting B cell responses and qualityantibody production. Thus, it is possible that PD-1 blockade enhances the efficacy of SARS-CoV-2 vaccination. However, PD-1 blockade in melanoma patients was actually associated with at 2-fold decrease in SARS-CoV-2specific antibodies and neutralizing antibodies, compared to a healthy donor cohort. PD-1 blockade was alsoassociated with depletion of memory CD4 T cells, suggesting there may be consequences to prolonged PD-1blockade.
ABSTRACT
Background: Recent studies have shown 5-yr recurrence rates for Stage IIB and IIC melanoma of up to 46%. These high-risk patients currently have few options for adjuvant therapy to prevent this inevitable recurrence, with the only FDA approved therapy being high-dose interferon-alfa, which is quite toxic. However, there are now immunotherapies (anti-PD1) and targeted therapies (anti-BRAF and anti-MEK combinations) which are approved as adjuvants for Stage III patients, some of whom will have a lower baseline recurrence risk than those with Stage IIB/IIC melanoma. We sought to determine if adjuvant PD1 inhibition with nivolumab (N) would improve the recurrence free survival (RFS) compared to historical RFS rates. Methods: Our study (NCT03405155) is a single-arm, open label, multicenter, phase 2 clinical trial evaluating RFS at 24 months in patients with Stage IIB/IIC melanoma on treatment with N at 480 mg IV every 4 weeks for 12 cycles. Overall survival is a secondary endpoint. Associated translational research includes circulating tumor cell DNA and immune correlates. Results: Twenty three patients with Stage IIB and three patients with Stage IIC melanoma were enrolled onto the study and received at least one dose of N. At data cutoff, 22 patients remain in follow up, as four patients withdrew consent at different time points in the study - one patient after one dose who wished to discontinue, one due to concern for COVID and need for repeat visits, one due to insurance issues, and one due to recurrence and wish to discontinue (which was captured in study data and RFS calculations). Seventeen patients have been on the clinical trial for at least two years with nine patients having finished treatment but with less than two years follow-up;the median follow-up is currently 21.9 months. Two patients demonstrated melanoma recurrence, one after receiving cycle six of N and another one year after completing treatment, resulting in a 87.8% RFS (90% CI (64.2%-96.3%) at 2 years, compared to the historical RFS at 2 years of 70%. No N related serious adverse events (SAEs) were observed, with only 2% Grade 3 AEs observed (varied and unrelated to treatment) and all others were Grade 1-2, including 21% GI, 18% cutaneous, and 10% musculoskeletal, respiratory, and fatigue, each;overall, 2% of these Grade 1-2 AEs were treatment related. Conclusions: Our preliminary results show a trend towards improved RFS in patients with Stage IIB/IIC melanoma treated with nivolumab. The cohort has not reached a minimum follow up of at least 2 years for RFS;patients are continuing to be monitored. On study, we observed the expected adverse events, without evidence of new toxicities. Data maturation will reveal the full effect of adjuvant N on disease relapse and overall survival and distant metastasis-free survival in stage IIB/IIC melanoma patients.